
Choosing US, UK, or Canadian Law for an Italian Will (EU Reg. 650/2012)
This legal briefing sets out the Italian rules and cross-border considerations for Choosing US, UK, or Canadian Law for an Italian Will (EU Reg. 650/2012) where UK, Irish, or international interests intersect with Italian law. It outlines statutory obligations, document formalities, and practical coordination within our Cross-Border Tax & Fiscal Coordination practice.

Cross-Border Tax & Fiscal Coordination
1. Choosing Your National Law in Italy
Under Article 21 of EU Regulation 650/2012, the default rule is that the law of the state where a person held habitual residence at death governs the whole estate. When an overseas owner lives in Italy or leaves real property in Italy without a valid election, Italian succession rules apply.
Italian law enforces legittima (forced heirship shares reserved by law for a spouse, children, and certain ascendants) under Articles 536 to 564 of the Codice Civile (Italian Civil Code). Those fixed shares restrict how freely an owner may leave Italian land or bank balances.
Article 22(1) of EU Regulation 650/2012 lets a non-Italian citizen elect the law of their nationality in a will to govern their entire succession. For the general framework and forced heirship interaction, see Brussels IV and Succession in Italy: The Regulatory Path and Forced Heirship in Italy: Avoiding the Conflicts.
2. Why Passports Do Not Match Succession Laws
A national passport identifies citizenship of a sovereign state, not one set of inheritance rules, whenever a person is a citizen of a federal or multi-unit country. There is no nationwide United States probate statute, no uniform Canadian succession code, and no single British inheritance law.
Each US state, Canadian province or territory, Australian state, and United Kingdom constituent jurisdiction (England and Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland) maintains distinct succession statutes and family claim rules. Under the British Nationality Act 1981, for instance, a single British citizenship covers three separate UK inheritance systems, while under the Fourteenth Amendment to the US Constitution, state citizenship follows state domicile rather than a national registry.
Ambiguity over which internal system governs affects Italian estate administration directly after death. Before heirs can transfer Italian property or close local accounts, an Italian notaio (civil-law notary) generally files the will through a verbale di pubblicazione (notarial deed formally filing a will) alongside foreign probate records, as detailed in The English Grant of Probate and Italian Assets: A Dual-Track Guide.
3. How EU Succession Rules Pick Your State or Country Law
EU Regulation 650/2012 sets out a two-step test in Article 36 for states that comprise two or more territorial legal units.
How Italy Identifies the Right State or Nation (Art. 36)
Under Step 1 (Article 36(1)), Italian authorities first look to the internal conflict-of-laws rules of the federal or multi-unit state itself to identify the governing territorial unit. Countries such as Spain operate uniform internal conflict rules through vecindad civil (regional civil status determining which Spanish regional law applies).
Because the USA, the UK, Canada, and Australia have no uniform nationwide internal conflict statute binding all units together, Step 2 (Article 36(2)(b)) falls back to a factual test. Where the deceased elected nationality under Article 22 or where nationality is applied, Article 36(2)(b) points to the territorial unit with which the deceased had the collegamento più stretto (closest connection), echoing Article 18 of Italian Law No. 218/1995.
Because Article 36(2)(b) uses a factual connection test, a testator cannot pick a state at random where they hold no genuine domicile, residency, or personal tie. Selecting Delaware, Nevada, or England solely for perceived estate flexibility fails under Italian and EU conflict rules if all factual ties point elsewhere.
When Foreign Law Sends Property Back to Italy (Renvoi)
Where a testator executes a valid express choice of law under Article 22(1), Article 34(2) of EU Regulation 650/2012 excludes renvoi (reference back by foreign conflict rules to Italian law). The internal succession law of the chosen state, province, or constituent UK nation applies directly to Italian movable and immovable assets.
By contrast, if a citizen of a third state such as the USA or UK dies habitually resident outside the EU without making a valid Article 22 election, Article 34(1) triggers renvoi back to Italian law under common-law lex rei sitae (law of the place where land sits) principles for Italian real estate. That renvoi places Italian land back under Italian legittima quotas.
4. US, UK, Canadian, and Australian Rules Compared
The table below summarizes internal territorial divisions, connection criteria, and internal forced-share or family claim rules across the four main common-law multi-unit nationalities.
| Nationality | Internal Territorial Legal Units | Article 36(2)(b) Connection Basis | Internal Forced Share / Family Claim Rules |
|---|---|---|---|
| United States | 50 states plus District of Columbia and territories | Fourteenth Amendment state citizenship turns on state domicile; Article 36(2)(b) looks to the state of closest connection (last US domicile, tax, and voter ties). | Common-law states allow spousal elective shares; community-property states split marital assets; Louisiana enforces forced heirship for qualifying descendants. |
| United Kingdom | England and Wales; Scotland; Northern Ireland | British Nationality Act 1981 confers one British citizenship; Article 36(2)(b) applies domicile of origin or choice to locate the constituent UK unit. | England and Wales and Northern Ireland allow testamentary freedom subject to dependants’ claims; Scotland enforces fixed statutory legal rights on movable estate. |
| Canada | 10 provinces and 3 territories | Provincial domicile governs movables and situs governs local land; Article 36(2)(b) identifies the province or territory of closest connection. | Common-law provinces apply dependants’ relief legislation; the Civil Code of Quebec enforces spousal family patrimony and support claims. |
| Australia | 6 states and 2 mainland territories | State or territory domicile and Australian internal conflict rules determine the closest sub-national unit under Article 36. | Each state and territory operates separate succession statutes and family provision legislation for eligible dependants. |
5. Typical Scenarios
The prospective scenarios below show how Articles 22 and 36 operate in practice when federal or multi-unit nationals hold assets in Italy.
Scenario 1: US Citizen Living in Italy With Ties to Two States
The Situation: A US citizen has lived in Rome for twenty years, owns a residence in Lazio, and previously held residences, tax filings, and property in both Massachusetts and Florida before moving to Italy.
The Legal Issue: Writing only "I elect US law" creates uncertainty under Article 36(2)(b) because competing relatives can argue for different US states, delaying the Italian notaio and risking challenge to the choice of law.
How We Handle It: We review the client’s domicile, voter registration, and personal records existing at the date of signing under Article 22(1), elect the specific state with the documented collegamento più stretto, and set out those factual ties in the Italian will.
Scenario 2: British Citizen With Ties to Scotland and England
The Situation: A British national born in Glasgow lived in Surrey for twenty-five years before buying a house in Tuscany and drafting a will electing "British law".
The Legal Issue: Under the British Nationality Act 1981, British citizenship does not distinguish between Scots law and English law, yet Scottish statutory legal rights (fixed shares on movable estate) differ sharply from English testamentary freedom.
How We Handle It: We name the internal law of England and Wales explicitly in a standalone Italian will, record the English domicile connections existing at signing, and confirm alignment with the client’s UK will.
Scenario 3: US Living Trust and an Italian Property
The Situation: A Texas couple holds brokerage portfolios inside a US revocable living trust and owns a farmhouse in Umbria needing future voltura catastale (Land Registry Title Registration) at the catasto (Italian land registry) on death.
The Legal Issue: A US revocable trust does not pass Italian real estate directly at the Italian land registry, and trust structures raise both Italian recognition and tax rules examined in Trusts in Italy: A Legal, Tax, and Conflict of Laws Framework and future departure considerations reviewed in Italy’s Proposed 2027 Individual Exit Tax: Pre-Move and Resident Trust Planning.
How We Handle It: We draft a standalone Italian will limited to Italian assets with an express Texas choice of law under Articles 22 and 36 so the Italian notaio can complete verbale di pubblicazione and voltura catastale cleanly alongside US counsel.
6. Four Practical Steps
Nationals of federal or multi-unit states owning Italian assets should follow four practical steps:
7. How we can help
PW Jennings Legal advises US, UK, Canadian, Australian, and Irish clients in Rome and across Italy on Article 22 and Article 36 choice-of-law clauses, standalone Italian wills, and parallel probate coordination.
We work directly alongside your home-country estate lawyers, Italian notai (civil-law notaries), and local litigators where court proceedings arise. Explore Cross-Border Wills, Probate & Italian Inheritance, review our Italian Property & Real Estate practice, or request a fixed-fee scope before executing an Italian will.
Notes for Professional Referrers
Referring advisers should examine Articles 22(1), 34(1)–(2), and 36(1)–(2)(b) of EU Regulation 650/2012 alongside Article 18 of Italian Law No. 218/1995 whenever advising nationals of federal or multi-unit states. Because Article 36(1) checks internal conflict rules (such as Spanish vecindad civil) before falling back to Article 36(2)(b) collegamento più stretto for the USA (Fourteenth Amendment state domicile), UK (British Nationality Act 1981 single citizenship), Canada, and Australia, wills should recite the factual domicile or connection ties existing at execution. Where a non-resident dies without a valid Article 22 election, lex rei sitae renvoi under Article 34(1) typically returns Italian real estate to Italian legittima shares. Contested validity or forced heirship proceedings in Italian courts are handled by coordinating with local litigators.
Frequently Asked Questions
How we can help
Speak with a dual-qualified UK, Irish, and Italian lawyer and receive a clear fixed-fee scope before work begins.